Back in the early 90s, the term “chaos theory” was often bandied about as THE FUTURE. It was never clear exactly what chaos theory would be THE FUTURE of, but it was clearly important stuff. Fast forward 20 years, and I’m finding all sorts of areas where chaos theory is relevant to musical audio.
One of the big concepts in chaos theory is self-similarity. This term is used to describe objects or processes that appear to be similar at different time scales. Self similarity can be found in the cragginess of a coastline, where zooming in at ever smaller resolutions results in similar craggy patterns. A classic visual representation of self-similarity from the early days of chaos theory was a simulated fern, where each leaf was the same pattern as the entire fern:
Feedback through a pitch shifter can be viewed as a DSP process that creates self-similarity. Each time the signal passes through the pitch shifter, a copy of the original signal is created, but at a different “size” (i.e. pitch) and different scale (i.e. the volume). If the pitch shifter used has a long enough window for its grains, each grain can end up containing copies of the original temporal detail of the input signal, scaled in both time and amplitude. Shifting a signal up by an octave, and feeding this back into the input of the shifter, will result in a signal that is self-similar at different frequency/wavelength scales.
For many natural processes, the details end up getting blurred at the smallest resolutions, due to the nature of the physical materials at these resolutions. This blurring is reminiscent of the “blurred self similarity” generated by the classic shimmer effect, where the signal is self-similar at different frequency scales, but the temporal details are lost.
Many natural processes can be viewed as self-similar random processes, where the scale of the randomness follows a 1/fn distribution. In other words, there is randomness happening at all frequencies/time scales, but the amplitude of that randomness falls off as a factor of frequency.
Self-similar randomness can be heard in glorious detail inside of a tape echo.
A highly damaged tape loop creates randomized pitch modulation at different time scales, that is far more complex than your typical sine LFO, or the “randi” modulator found in the Music N computer music languages. Mix this pitch modulation in with the dry input signal, and the result is a natural doubling sound. Turn up the echo time and feedback, and the result is a huge ambient sound, where the complex pitch variation produces a rich, organic wash.
nice relation of DSP to organic processes
Yeah, that’s not even subtle hinting anymore 😉
Looking forward to the results of your musings.
Oh man… a Valhalla Tape Plug = just take my money.
love your plugins sean, interesting post too. on the subject of 1/f noise & self-similarity – human rhythm errors exhibit this – which might be a part of why we like it in our delays?
http://www.pnas.org/content/111/36/12974.abstract / https://www.ableton.com/en/blog/james-holden-human-timing/
(links are science paper/more waffley article)
Have you seen my stuff on chaos? I believe chaos is the future. It will become a self-fulfilling prophecy if it has to. I believe, in the future, it will be difficult to find a synth that is not making heavy use of chaos theory for its underlying sound generation. I believe chaos should be used as an antialiasing technique.
See my videos :
chaos-based antialiasing: https://youtu.be/eF7KeF9NEMM
chaotic, fractal, self-similar spiral demo: https://youtu.be/jz1s7PF_Cao
I think not only is chaos/fractal/self-similarity extremely important, it has been with us all along as you said with your example of the old tape delay, and let me add another example: The quintessential filtered saw. Not only has chaos theory been secretly hiding in the crevices of our musical tools, we, humanity, have been craving more of it. Why is the dubstep vocal bass so enthralling? It’s because it approaches a fractal/self-similar/chaotic sound. I believe the filtered saw started it all. It is the staple of synth music because it is fractal/self-similar in nature. Analog filters are chaos machines and we can’t get enough of it. Now it’s time to go beyond that, more powerful, more musical, more expressive. Forget about “subtractive synths”, I believe it is a concept that has largely failed to deliver on its promises.
The future is exciting! The future *s organic chaos synthesis.
Organic processes display similarity not only at different sizes/scales, but in completely different areas. A head of broccoli looks similar in shape to the alveoli in a lung, or for that matter, in an udder. Various shapes just work, so nature applies them “across disciplines”.